orgma

Orgma guides · Choosing your training system

Excel training matrix vs training software: which is right for your team?

A practical comparison for people responsible for staff training records, certificates and renewals.

Published by Orgma ·

A certificate arrives in your inbox. You check the details, update the training matrix, save the file and make a note to arrange the next renewal. Each step is straightforward. Keeping every step up to date across your team is where the work builds up.

Excel can be a good way to manage that work. Training software becomes useful when updating the spreadsheet, finding evidence and chasing renewals starts taking more effort than it should. This guide compares the two approaches, using our own Orgma Training Tracker as the software example.

Excel and training software at a glance

Start with the work you need to do each week. A feature matters when it makes that work easier or gives you a clearer view of your records.

How the same training admin tasks work in each system
TaskExcel training matrixOrgma Training Tracker
Adding certificatesYou enter the details or arrange an import, then link or file the evidence.Upload certificate photos or PDFs. Orgma reads the details for you to check and confirm.
Spotting certificate expiryFormulas and conditional formatting can highlight approaching or expired dates. Someone maintains the rules and reviews the workbook.Expiry tracking flags what needs renewing alongside your training records.
Finding evidenceYou can link to certificate files. Your team needs a consistent filing system and access to the linked files.Original evidence stays with the training record, so you can find the certificate behind an entry.
Working with colleaguesSupported versions allow coauthoring through OneDrive or SharePoint Online. Workbook access and editing rules need managing.Colleagues use individual accounts and permissions to work with the same records.
Preparing for a reviewYou organise the workbook, supporting files and any record of changes for the reviewer.The training matrix, exports and audit trail help you prepare records and trace changes.

On a smaller screen, scroll across the comparison table. Microsoft explains the available conditional formatting and Excel coauthoring options.

When Excel is a sensible choice

A spreadsheet can work well when your training requirements are straightforward, records change infrequently and someone has clear responsibility for keeping them current. It is flexible, familiar to many teams and lets you arrange columns around your own roles and qualifications.

For example, a small catering business might have one manager who maintains the matrix, checks upcoming renewals regularly and keeps certificates in a shared folder. If colleagues can find what they need and updates are reliable, that may be a perfectly workable system.

Excel can also support formulas, colour coding and shared editing. The question is whether your actual workbook is set up and maintained to do what your team needs. If you are starting from scratch, our guide explains what to include in a training matrix.

When training software starts to earn its place

The pressure often comes from how records move between people. A manager receives a certificate, an administrator updates the matrix and someone else prepares the evidence for a review. If those steps happen in separate inboxes and folders, it becomes easier for an update to stall.

These are useful signs to look for:

  • You enter the same information repeatedly. Names, course titles and dates are copied from certificates into different records.
  • The matrix and evidence drift apart. A row says training is current, but finding the certificate takes another round of emails.
  • Renewal checks depend on one person. When that person is busy or away, nobody is sure what needs attention.
  • Several colleagues need to update records. You spend time resolving versions or working out who changed an entry.
  • Reviews create a last minute scramble. The information exists, but assembling it is a job in itself.

Headcount alone does not settle the decision. A small care team with several roles and frequent training updates may have a more demanding recordkeeping process than a larger team whose requirements rarely change.

Compare the cost and the ongoing work

If you already have Excel, a matrix may involve no additional software purchase. It still takes time to maintain the workbook, check dates, file certificates and prepare information for other people. A software subscription adds a visible cost and needs setup, so judge it against the work it actually helps your team complete.

During your next normal update, note how long it takes to add a certificate, find its original and identify upcoming renewals. Try those same tasks in the system you are considering. Include a colleague who will use it regularly, then compare the results with your own experience rather than a promised saving.

Before choosing software, check the current allowances for people, colleague access, certificate reading and storage. Also check how you can export your records. Our pricing page lists Orgma's plans so you can compare them with your team's needs.

What to try in Orgma Training Tracker

Orgma Training Tracker brings certificate reading, training records, the training matrix and expiry tracking together. You review the details Orgma reads, while the original evidence stays available with the record. Exports and an audit trail support preparation for reviews.

Try a small sample that reflects your everyday work: a few people in different roles, a certificate approaching expiry and a record with missing evidence. Check whether you and a colleague can answer these questions easily:

  1. What training does this person have, and what is still missing?
  2. Which certificates need attention next?
  3. Can we open the evidence behind a matrix entry?
  4. Can we prepare the records we need for a review?

Your team still checks the evidence, sets training requirements and decides whether training is suitable. Orgma organises the records and flags dates; it does not contact issuers or verify certificate authenticity.

See how your training records could work together.
Upload your certificates, check the details and build your team's training matrix.

Create my free training matrix

No payment card needed.

If you decide to switch

Keep your current workbook while you check the new system with a sample of real records. Once you are satisfied it fits, use our separate guide to replacing an Excel training matrix for the migration checklist.

For either approach, a clear owner and a regular review routine make the records more useful. Our guide to tracking certificate expiry explains how to turn upcoming dates into planned follow up.